Uday's News Picks
CNN Headlines

"The best way to predict the future is to create it." - Peter Drucker, Management Guru

Monday
29Jun

Value Pricing

Here is a quick quiz - do you remember your 4 marketing Ps? I bet you do. Did you know that of those four Ps, pricing is the primary revenue generating element, with the rest largely anchored as cost centers? Even though pricing brings money in, the typical marketing department spends the least amount of effort on this very important activity. There is too much fun to be had designing the product, promoting it, and placing it; who would want to get into the boring world of pricing. Let’s just look at our competitor’s prices and use that as a basis for setting a price.

I hate to be the bearer of bad news but that approach will not get you too far in your endeavors. Pricing is often done in haste, utilizing what I call incomplete information. A thorough approach to pricing requires you to leverage micro economics, managerial accounting, supply chain analysis, and human psychology, along with the typical marketing knowledge areas. Only pricing strategy and decisions based on this set of complete information can be called sound. Anything short of this rigor and discipline will result in one of the two scenarios –

  1. A product that is priced too high, which further results in -
    • Products never fully developing their target market segment
    • Company leaving opportunity for competition to read the pricing signal, loud and clear, and move into sharing the economic rents you had planned on generating
  2. A product that is priced too low, which further results in -
    • Company giving away millions of $s by not effectively tapping into all of the consumer surplus
    • Company depriving itself of precious profits needed to finance its future growth and product lines

What throws the biggest of all wrenches in this process is that the impact of the pricing strategy and decision, good or bad, is not fully understood until it is too late. In case of a bad pricing decision, the outcome is often detrimental to the future of the business/company as valuable time, effort, money, and opportunity would have been lost.

Here is a great analogy (at least in my mind) that I was able to come up with. Pricing is like cooking – the quality of your cooking, and hence its value, improves as you spend more time in the kitchen. You may start off by following the recipe book but eventually you know the right mix of ingredients that must go into the dish in order to make it delicious. You deviate from the recipe and create your own version, with a bit of red wine, a dash of lemon, some garam masala, etc. You become more of an artist, than a machine that just follows steps and orders. That is the precise reason why experts say that pricing is an art, not a science.

Here is another important point that you should get out of your head – that there is some sort of tight-knit relationship between pricing and cost. Just forget it. Now if you are in the commodity business, yes, I agree. In such a case, you are a “price taker”, not a “price setter”. You go to the spot market, check the price(s), and that is what the customer will pay for your product. Your product can be sourced from multiple other suppliers/channels and your product has no meaningful differentiation from the competitors. Your price is going to be pretty close to what the marginal cost of producing the next widget (i.e. product) is and that is all what you can get away with.

But, if you are in the business of selling differentiated products, products that provide a relatively measurable and distinguishable advantage over their comparables, products that are fairly targeted and customized to specific market segments, you ought to ignore the product manufacturing costs in the beginning. Try to understand the additional/incremental value your product provides to the consumer. Put yourself in the consumer’s shoes and ask “how much is this product worth to me?” “How does this product improve my productivity, my image, my agility, my comfort, etc. above and beyond my current capabilities/worth?” Once you understand the consumer value of your product, then you are in a position to put a price to it. You should still do the cost-plus computation and also look at other product substitute value and prices, to validate and rationalize your product pricing.

My bottom-line recommendation is that you take a multi-pronged approach, work of a complete set of information, and then converge on a price that the market can bear. Be clear on what your product launch strategy is – are you trying to maximize profit margins, grab the leader position in your market, or striving for something in between? Accordingly, your pricing strategy must change and so should your resulting product price. As always, be sure to take a minute and share your feedback or experience.

Reference: Marketing High Technology by William Davidow.

Monday
22Jun

Healthcare's Declining Health

So what is bugging you these days? Energy, drugs, tobacco, politics, Iran, unemployment, the automotive sector, our primary education system - take your pick. There are plenty of choices out there these days. But then there is one problem that seems to have been around for the longest time - Healthcare.

We are about to wrap up the first decade of the 21st century and healthcare continues to become more high tech, expensive, complicated, and to quite a few out there, elusive. One would have logically concluded that with time, there would be productivity improvements and this would drive the costs down. But the fact is that despite there being improvements in procedures, hardware, software, etc., healthcare costs have kept going up and up. Some blame it on the expensive equipment and devices that the suppliers keep pushing into the system, which the doctors have to keep utilizing to justify their costs. Others say the costs are high due to the constant barrage of medical malpractice law suits that the providers have to insure themselves against. Yet others say that the providers have no clue about what their true costs are and tend to charge figures that are guestimated based on what the market is willing to bear.

Based on my research and assessment, the healthcare sector is probably the most inefficient sector in all of the industry. There is a lot of waste in terms of drugs, devices, and diagnostics. There is a lot of duplicity of effort, sub-optimal utilization of energy, reliance on paper, and lack of process transformation. There is a glut of information, which in turn is not organized in a manner that is readily accessible, transferable, reliable, or trend-able. Information sharing and collaboration across service providers is lacking. Private practices, clinics, and small businesses have very little incentive to innovate and transform there operations since they have a captive customer base – us – their patients. Despite a large number of providers, true competition and a will to change is lacking.

Let me share a visual that I came across that will tell you why healthcare is so inefficient, cludgy, and out of touch with reality. Instead of moving to solutions that are based on human interactions and usability, the healthcare IT sector continues to produce applications that are transaction oriented. Its another fine example of the clutter that has been the hallmark of our fat and obese healthcare system. Be sure to leave your reactions/comments to this visual.

Wednesday
10Jun

How the Mighty Fall?

Damn you Naseem Taleb. Ever since I read your books “Fooled by Randomness” and “The Black Swan” (previously reviewed on Kazira.com), they have completely ruined my intellectual life. I was happy in my gullible way of thinking that

•          - The whole world could be pretty much modeled by Gaussian curve

           - Economists are all honest folks

           - Media is honest and unbiased

           - Supreme court is honest and unbiased and

           - Bear Sterns is a rock solid company

You have ruined it all for me by opening up my eyes to the reality. I can no longer be fooled by the phony economists and phony writers anymore. I can smell bullshit coming from a mile away. Which brings me to this book – “How the Mighty Fall????” By Jim Collins.

You may recognize this author’s name – because he has written two of the most successful business books “Good to Great” and “Built to Last”. One of my wise friends had said that there are some companies really applying the principles laid out in “Good to Great” very religiously. I never read that book but thought very highly of the author due to other’s recommendations. This is the reason I bought this one!!! What a mistake this was? I shall never get back the time and the money I spent on buying and reading this book. I almost threw the book away after reading the first few pages. But then I read the rest for entertainment purposes only.

So, let me tell you what is happening here. Mr. Collins ego is hurt since some of the exemplary companies that he used to derive his conclusions for his previous books, have been destroyed during the current economic crisis. General thinking here is that – Since his books have sold millions of copies and so many people are applying the concepts laid out in those books – He must come up with this pile of “you know what” to justify the fact that his previous assertions are still valid despite the invalidation of key data used to generate the assertions (Not to mention that the data was selectively chosen and was sparse to begin with). Instead of just coming out and saying that “oopps, I messed up” and “don’t buy my books till I revise concepts” ; he has come out with another one to explain away the outliers in his already small sample of data. And he has filled the rest of the pages with generic, superficial blabber about the stages companies go through as they decline. The zest of the stages laid out by him were laid out by my mom 30 years ago – Don’t be arrogant, don’t be greedy, be honest and hardworking, etc.

Going back to Mr. Taleb now. We have learnt that black swans can and do happen. So to answer his question of “How the mighty fall??” Its because of Black Swans. Modeling scalable systems in Extremistan is impossible. Success is preliminary due to chances and luck. So on and so forth. So, laying out handful of principles that may apply to only a handful of available sample data is futile. When the luck runs out, or Black Swans emerge; the companies fail (no matter how well your plans and intentions are). There is no way you can get a model for luck, chance, and external forces. The distribution is NOT Gaussian for you to define these in a nice bowed-down package. And then, as if this is not enough, claiming that you can detect the initial precursor of tremors of decline is just outrageous.

This book reminds me of Tom Peter – who confessed a few years or so ago about falsifying data to support his classic work “In search of Excellence”. We’ll look back and definitely see that the principles laid out by my mom are more solid and enduring than the ones laid out by this author.

I should not write more lest my blood boils and I’ll end up damaging my leftover neurons ...

Save your money and stay away from this book.

 

Tuesday
09Jun

Sustaining Customer Satisfaction

Times are tough. Sales are down. Budgets are being slashed. In times like these, how are you going to sustain those high services levels that your customers got so used to getting? Just a while back, you were doing really good and spending all kinds of money on resources and initiatives that helped you get those coveted JD Power awards, Fastest Growing Company recognitions, etc. Now that the environment is not so friendly, you’ve been asked to cut and rip through every line item on your customer operations budget and that means cutting back on 24x7 support, live chat, promotional campaigns, free returns, store specials, etc. But are you sure that is smart thing to do? Do you really want to take the risk of alienating your current/potential customers when, across the board, demand is on the decline and customers are thinking twice about their purchases/brand-loyalties?


Customers are like kids – once they start liking something, they do not like when it is taken away, when the fact is that they want more of it! Don’t blame them – you are the one who rolled out the red carpet in the first place and told them that you will treat them better than the competition. Now that the weather conditions are not that favorable, you want to pull that carpet. Not so fast my friend, unless you are thinking about getting out of your business.


So the next logical question is how should you go about designing a more optimal, cost-effective, and satisfaction-focused customer support program? It depends on the answers you come up for the following questions -

  1. How important/critical is customer satisfaction to your business and brand? How does it impact sales, profitability, customer churn, customer retention, etc.?
  2. How competitive is your environment? Meaning, how easily can people trade-down/up or substitute for your product(s)?
  3. How much does it take to acquire a new customer? How much does it take to keep an existing customer?
  4. How complex is your product? Is it simple to work with and trouble-shoot or is it difficult?
  5. How visible is your product? Is it something that sits in a corner, inside a room, or is it something that is out in the open?

Once you start asking the above questions (and more), you will start to understand the linkages between customer satisfaction and sales, profitability, brand equity, stock price, talent retention, inventory levels, product returns/recalls, call center utilization, etc. Here is an approach you may want to utilize when in the process of re-designing your customer support operations –

  1. Start by documenting what I call “Customer Satisfaction Drivers(CSD) that are specific to your line of business. CSDs are performance metrics like Average Response Time, Average Resolution Time, MTBF (Mean Time Between Failures), etc., which you strive to measure and control since they tell you how well/poorly you are performing.
  2. Next understand the true costs of supporting your customer operations. I strongly urge that you use something like an ABC (activity based costing) approach so that you are accounting for each and every task that contributes to the customer operations.
  3. Build the linkages between the activities that are done to support customer operations and the end benefit/outcome of the activity to the customer, company, and partners. To get an idea of what I am suggesting, check out the Strategy Map that I had published in one of my earlier blog postings.
  4. Once you’ve captured the CSDs, estimated the costs, and documented the benefits, conduct a cost-benefit analysis of every support activity and prioritize it accordingly. You will need to utilize some sort of weighted average approach that gives every activity a single score that encapsulates both the cost and the benefit of the activity. Be sure to map the appropriate CSDs to each activity.
  5. Finally, create a “Customer Value Wagon Wheel” (i.e. a pie chart) that will visually tell you what activities provide your organization with a highest ROI. You will now have a more scientific and data-driven model to have any discussions on cost cutting and their resulting impact on business.

If you follow the above approach or something similar to it and be diligent in its execution, there is no reason why you can’t start driving your support costs down while sustaining the Customer QoS (Quality of Service) and scores. Be sure to comment on my ideas and contribute your own. 

Sunday
31May

Transparent Innovation

So you think you are at the cutting edge of innovation? Well good, prove it to me. Don't just prove it, show it to me! While you are thinking on how to answer my question, here is a real-world example for you from the leading auto maker of the world - VolksWagen (VW). In the world of marketing, we talk about "Observability" as one of the key attributes for the adoption of innovation. Does the customer have the ability to be able to clearly view and observe the benefits of the product?

VW has been at the forefront of making cars but the ability to showcase their innovation to their customers and enthusiasts was limited to taking a peek inside the car, under the hood, or taking it for a spin. VW has now decided to take it a step further, in fact leapfrog ahead of their competition by building the world's very first "Transparent Factory". Now you can see your car being built, all the way from the paint shop to the final quality inspections. Sure this must have taken a lot of planning, funding, vision, and passion, but what VW is really demonstrating here is that they have something compelling to show case, something that further demonstrates to the market and their customers why they are the best in the business. This is marketing at its best! Lets see how the Toyotas, Hondas, etc. of the world are going to match this move. Still not impressed, check out the YouTube video.